Sunday, 14 December 2014

Minamishima, Melbourne - 11 December 2014

I wasn't planning on visiting Minamishima. In fact I had never heard of Minamishima til the weekend before I flew down to Melbourne for a business trip. My wife was browsing around Instagram one night and randomly discovered Minamishima, a sushi-ya that was describe to be "just like Japan". Being the sushi nut that I am, I declared that I needed to visit Minamishima. Fortunately, I was able to secure a Thursday night booking quite easily as they had only just opened for about a month and are not that widely known... yet.

Sushi chefs displaying their craft (Koichi Minamishima in background)
Minamishima was opened by chef Koichi Minamishima in November after spending many years at Kenzan as their sushi chef. Minamishima is located in a quiet, nondescript space just off Bridge Road in Richmond. The dining room is just like a sushi-ya in Japan. Diners are seated along a wooden counter (with enough seating for twelve) and get to watch two sushi chefs meticulously prepare each piece. There are also a few tables at the back for groups, but the seats at the sushi bar are the best seats in the house!

Table setting at Minamishima
There is no menu at Minamishima. Instead there is a $150 omakase menu that consists of an appetiser, 15 pieces of nigiri sushi, shinjo-wan (fish dumpling in clear broth) and one dessert. You can also choose to have sake or wine pairings for $70. I opted for the sake pairings. Like the food, the sakes start off light, making its way up to stronger and richer sakes.    

Appetiser: pumpkin, mustard greens, eggplant, tomato
The meal started with an appetiser of assorted vegetables. There was a tomato cooked in dashi, eggplant cooked in a sweet and savoury sauce, mustard greens topped with bonito flakes and pumpkin. Each of these vegetables were well cooked and enjoyable. 
King Dory
The first nigiri of the night was king dory.The king dory had a firm texture and a mild, sweet flavour. This piece was already seasoned with light soy by the sushi chef.

The first sake of my sake pairing was Kirei Shuzo Karakuchi 80 Junmai Nama Genshu from Hiroshima. This was a light refreshing sake that was dry on the palate, which went well with the milder flavoured fish early in the omakase menu.

Seared alfonsino
The next piece was seared alfonsino from New Zealand. The texture of this piece was soft and melting in the mouth and the gentle sweetness of the alfonsino was paired with grated radish.

King George Whiting
Alfonsino was quickly followed up with King George Whiting. This was the first piece where the chef instructed me to use soy sauce. The King George Whiting was impeccably fresh and a shiso leaf was hidden underneath to add a refreshing, peppery note to the whiting's subtle flavours.  

Next was octopus from Western Australia. The octopus was pleasingly tender whilst still retaining a slightly chewy texture. There was a nice depth of flavour that was brought out by tsume.       

The texture of calamari was amazing! The calamari was expertly scored to tenderise the flesh, which gave it an almost milky texture. The calamari was simply seasoned with lemon and shiso salt to draw out the sweetness of the calamari.  

Japan may have botan ebi, but scampi (from New Zealand) is a more than capable substitute. This scampi had an intense sweetness and a beautifully creamy flesh. Mindblowingly good!

The next sake was Dewazakura Junmai Ginjo Dewa Sansan from Yamagata. This sake was soft and deep flavoured with a good amount of acidity and a clean, crisp finish.      

Tairagai (pen shell)
The next three pieces were shellfish that Minamishima has imported from Japan. All three were special and are rarely seen in Japanese restaurants in Australia. 

Tairagai is a bit like scallop except I think tairagi has a better texture for sushi. The meat is firmer and more much substantial. This piece was seared, which brought out even more of the tairagai's sweetness and umami. This was my favourite out of the three Japanese shellfish.

Mirugai (geoduck)
Mirugai (from Japan) was cut into strips and topped onto a block of rice and wrapped with nori to form a gunkan. I loved the crunchy texture of the geoduck, which was sweet and carried the aroma of the sea.      

Torigai (cockle)
Next was torigai (also from Japan). It had a slightly chewy and springy texture. The cockle's sweet flavour was paired with ginger. 

Engawa (flounder fin)
Engawa (the muscle of the dorsal fin of the Japanese flounder) was pure bliss! This part of the flounder has a high fat content, which made it very soft and melting in the mouth. There was an incredible depth of flavour and the sweet aroma of the engawa spread across my palate.

The third sake from the sake pairing was Terada Honke Katori 90% Junmai Kimoto Muroka Nama Guenshu from Chiba. The sommelier explained that this sake was produced using older, traditional methods, a rarity these days. The sake had a lovely rich rice flavour with refreshing acidity and a delicate floral aroma. 

Maguro otoro (bluefin tuna belly)
I moved from one orgasmic moment to the next with this maguro otoro (bluefin tuna belly from Japan). There are very good reasons why the otoro is so highly prized. The flavour of otoro is just unrivalled: so deep, complex and rich in umami. And the flesh was ridiculously smooth, seemingly just melting away on the tongue. This was piece so good that I wanted to cry!

Naka Shuzo Asahi Wakatsu Junmai Muroka Nama Genshu from Tokushima was selected to be paired with otoro. This sake was rich, with fruity and spicy notes and a woody finish. This was my favourite sake of the sake pairing.             

Aburi otoro (seared bluefin tuna belly)
Otoro was then given the blowtorch treatment (aburi) to melt some of the fat into the flesh. Predictably, this piece was heavenly with a buttery mouth feel and amazing flavour.   

Battera (pressed mackerel)
Next was battera, an Osaka style pressed mackerel sushi. The mackerel was cured in rice vinegar, which provided a wonderful balance to the oiliness and strong flavour of the the mackerel. This piece was amazing and confirmed why I enjoy mackerel so much in sushi.

The next pairing, Pennyweight Constance fino from Beechworth, Victoria, was actually a wine rather than a sake, as the sushi chef wanted something richer to go with the remaining stronger flavour pieces. As I am not much of a wine drinker, I would have preferred sake.       

Anago (conger eel)
The next piece was another pressed sushi, this time with anago (conger eel or saltwater eel from Japan). The eel was so soft and evaporated instantly in the mouth, like a souffle from Vue de Monde. The sauce was sweet and filled with umami. I did think with the softness of the eel, that the block of rice was a bit big. 

Uni (sea urchin)
I love sea urchin and my eyes lit up when I saw the chef fill a little dish of cucumber with Bafun uni from Hokkaido. The rich, creamy texture of the sea urchin was heavenly in the mouth. A heavy sweetness and aroma of the sea urchin filled my mouth. The crispness of the cucumber worked well as a base for the sea urchin, but I think I have a preference for rice.

Maguro otoro (bluefin tuna belly) - extra $22
After the sea urchin, the sushi chef indicated to me that I had final piece in the omakase menu and asked whether I wanted any more pieces. I decided to order another piece of otoro, since the first piece was so orgasmic and I was here any way, so I may as well make the most of my visit. This might be the most expensive single bite I've ever had, but it was totally worth it because otoro is one of life's greatest pleasures!

Shinjo-wan (kingfish and calamari dumpling in clear broth)
The final savoury course of the omakase menu was shinjo (a dumpling made from kingfish and calamari), submerged in a clear dashi broth. The flavours of this course were clean, refreshing and really delicious!

The final pairing of the night was Ota Shuz┼Ź Dokan Umeshu from Hyogo, a sake infused with ume or plum. This was one of the best ume-shus that I have ever had. The tart flavours of ume were wonderfully balanced with moderate sweetness, creating a ume-shu that was really pleasant to drink and not sickly sweet.

Rice milk pudding
rice milk pudding with a dark sugar syrup from Okinawa and summer fruits (raspberry, strawberry and dark grape) was served for dessert. Dessert was simple yet highly enjoyable. I loved the smoothness and the creaminess of the pudding. This dessert was served with a cup of hojicha (roasted Japanese green tea). 

Massive damage done to my bank account!
Minamishima is not cheap, but then again neither are high end sushi-yas in Japan, which Minamishima is trying to emulate. Despite only being open for a month, Minamishima has done an outstanding job in creating an exquisite sushi omakase experience in Australia. Each piece was amazing and there is no doubt that the sushi chefs here are some of the best in the country (alongside Sano-san of Sokyo). Minamishima is probably the best option Australians have for a true sushi omakase experience, outside of booking a flight to Japan and eating at one of the Michelin star sushi-yas.

Highlight: Otoro!
Lowlight: No tamago (egg omelette) to end the sushi omakase.
Overall: Minamishima is a sushi-ya, just like those found in Japan. This was probably the best sushi that I have eaten in Australia. Sushi fans, take note before Minamishima becomes difficult to book! 9/10 (Outstanding)

Address: 4 Lord St, Richmond VIC 3121 
Contact no: (03) 9429 5180

Minamishima on Urbanspoon 


  1. You really can't do this to me Chris. First Sokyo and now Minamishima? I've got a long way to go before I can wear sushi cufflinks myself!

    1. Hi Michael, don't worry I won't be doing this to you for much longer, unless more sushi places like Sokyo and Minamishima start opening. Haha yes those cufflinks. I am such a geek :P

  2. LOL why a vegetarian recommends decent non vegetarian restaurants are always amusing... Many thanks to Black Market Sake (IG: @blackmarketsake) for putting up pictures of Minamishima's sushi

    1. And thanks to Black Market for supplying some really awesome sakes to leading restaurants in Sydney and Melbourne :)

    2. Your secret is out now

    3. It was never going to be low profile for long!

  3. Hahaha I see Shirley must know your tastebuds extremely well to be able to make non-vegetarian recommendations. Reading this post didn't make my decision any easier - it should be an obvious yes but I've already booked Nobu and Maggie really wants to go. I know it's not a fair comparison and one cannot replace the other. nor can one have enough sushi but that's 2/4 days in Melbourne. Absolute dilemma!!! But that otoro sure looks good, and I want to try pressed sushi, and I want to try Taraigai!

    1. Hi Crystal, she has to put with my ramblings on a daily basis, so of course she knows my taste buds better than anyone, despite being a vegetarian :P

      It sounds like you already have an exciting and packed schedule for Melbourne! Minamishima is a premium experience, so if budget wasn't a concern, this place is a must do for a sushi lover like yourself. You will be assureed that based on this meal, they will have a lot of success and will be around for the long run, so there will be a next time if you decide not to go this time! Plus we have Sokyo in Sydney, so amazing sushi is not far away :D

    2. Budget isn't a concern.. and for some reason I want to try Minamishima more than Nobu (don't tell Maggie that and she won't see this because she doesn't read our blogs hahahhaa). I know Maggie will say yes to whatever, but Cutler & Co., Coda, Chin Chin...

      I'm sure Minamishima will be around, but I want to go while they are still low profile, and because your experience sounds sooooo good. That's true - Sokyo is not far away in distance nor time, we're going in January right?

    3. Haha yes Maggie doesn't read our blogs so say what you want haha

      I suspect Minamishima will be a lot more popular when the food critics get onto it in the new year. Btw you don't need to fret over whether to go or not cos they're closed over the Christmas period.

      And Sokyo in the new year, lock it in!

  4. What a fantastic find and well done to your wife for finding it! My friend finds some great stuff through IG!

    1. Hi Lorraine, I agree Instagram is a great place to discover hidden gems :)

  5. that otoro looks so good.... and interesting to see some of the shellfish that's imported from Japan. I've never even heard of tairagai before but definitely putting it on the list to try!

    1. Hi Jacq, otoro = heaven! I've never tried tairagai too til now (really delicious but am slightly worried about the carbon miles to get these shellfish over here)...

  6. Dear Chris,

    The maguro otoro looks divine. What's your view on bluefin tuna sustainability?

    1. Thanks ChopinandMysaucepan, this is something that I do feel strongly about but I will try to keep it brief.

      There is no substitute for bluefin tuna, period. It is unrivalled in flavour and texture. But we all need to take responsibility for the depletion of bluefin tuna stocks worldwide.

      I am certainly in favour for more sustainable fishing methods and I think that we all should learn to enjoy a wider variety of seafood (e.g. we need to reduce our tuna and salmon intake) and focus on species that are actually sustainable. The right thing to do is obviously to turn our backs on bluefin tuna, but I am torn. Should I occasionally enjoy one of the MOST delicious things in the world (i.e. contribute to the problem) or should I not consume any bluefin tuna and still be left with the prospect of having a world with no bluefin tuna. A larger scale behavioural shift needs to occur for the bluefin tuna to be saved (which is unlikely to happen, to be honest).

  7. Ooof, hefty bill! I'd probably skip the pairings and just go for the menu. The shinjo looks like the perfect way to cleanse the palate before moving onto dessert.

    1. Hi Amanda, yep this is a pricey experience for sure, one that I think is worth the price tag given how much I enjoyed it! The sake or wine pairing is totally optional and by no means necessary. I enjoy drinking sake so that's why I went for it. I find that sushi enhances the flavour of sake rather than the other way around (could just be me though).

  8. Wow - what a great review,,,, and how right you were, with Minamishima taking out 2 hats and being awarded Restaurant of the Year in the AGFG for 2016. Going tonight - cannot wait!

    1. Thanks Jon! Much appreciated. It really is a fantastic experience! I hope you have an enjoyable meal and have seats at the sushi bar :)

  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    1. There is nothing similar to the Minamishima experience in Sydney unfortunately! The best sushi in Sydney is at Sokyo. Their sushi omakase (which requires pre booking via email) is very popular and definitely worth the effort required to get a table. I've written about it on the blog if you are interested. For a more affordable sushi omakase meal, HaNa JuRin in Crows Nest do a good omakase menu. All the best with the move to Sydney!

    2. This comment has been removed by the author.